• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Hickory House Restaurant: Your Destination for Mouthwatering Steaks and Seafood

At Hickory House Restaurant, nestled in Reynoldsburg, OH, we celebrate a rich tradition of culinary excellence where steakhouses meet seafood. Our story is rooted in a commitment to quality, evident in our award-winning ribs, juicy steaks, and flavorful seafood dishes. The cozy, log cabin ambiance invites families and groups to enjoy a memorable dining experience, while our extensive vegetarian options ensure everyone feels welcome. With attentive service, unique specialties like sautéed mushrooms and house-made dressings, and a reputation for superb barbecue, Hickory House is more than just a restaurant—it’s a cherished community gathering spot dedicated to great food and cherished moments.

Hickory House Restaurant at a glance

  • Address 7051 E Main St Reynoldsburg, OH 43068 United States
  • Phone (614) 861-5962
  • Restaurant type Steak house , American restaurant , Barbecue restaurant , Family restaurant , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Hickory House Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Don Elliott
5

It’s been a few years since we’ve been to the Hickory House so we decided to give it a try for a pre Thanksgiving dinner with an old neighbor. Our server Nancy was excellent and even surprised us with some homemade fudge after our meal! Everyone’s food was delicious and my wife’s steak was cooked to perfection. No complaints about anything and a good time was had. We will definitely be back

Jeffrey Viviani
5

If I broke my ribs and my mother said, "Oh, Jeffrey, I feel so bad. We'll go wherever you want." I'd say: let's go to Hickory House and get some ribs. Enough said. I will say, as rib man myself, it ranks second on my personal list. I would put their ribs into a holiday calender that is food-themed, because the appearance to the eye was just as pleasing as the taste to the tongue. The atmosphere is very nice in here, too. Spacious, actually. Service was wonderful. I love the wooden interior. Gets my approval.

Nichole Ball
5

The food here is to die for. Is it an exaggeration to say I want this to be my last meal? Mark, our server, was amazing. It was a busy Saturday night and we waited about an hour (worth it) and he knew we were HUNGRY. He brought us our food super quick and was so friendly. :) We will be back again and again and again.

Karina Sofia
5

We attended an event held here, both Nancy and Falon were AMAZING. Everyone was complimenting their service, they were so helpful, sweet, and kind. I had never been here before but I definitely want to come back soon!! Also get their spiked blueberry lemonade, Im not even a blueberry fan but this drink was perfect, thanks for the recommendations!!!

Mark M
4

The Hickory House had excellent bbq ribs and sides. The ribs were tender and moist. The salads that our group ate had a variety of delicious dressings on them. All of the dressings were tasty. We all chose loaded baked potatoes and they were large with plenty of bacon, cheese, sour cream and butter. The staff was friendly and helpful. Refills were provided quickly and without request. The building is older and dimly lit but was clean and uncluttered.

Hanh
5

Had a lovely Valentine’s dinner at the Hickory House. Nancy was very nice and took great care of us. Food was really good. They’re known for their steaks and ribs! Truly a gem in Reynoldsburg.

Tim Hales
5

Enjoy a taste of home cooking here. Could not have enjoyed our meal more. Pretty sure everything from the salad dressing to the barbecue sauce to the bread is homemade in house. We will be back!

Lakishia Lady Bug
5

Orders hot and fresh, made to order. The salad was fresh, along with freshly baked bread. The server (KELLI) was Everything! Very professional yet personable. It's a local proud family business.

Location

  • Hickory House Restaurant
    Hickory House Restaurant
    7051 E Main St Reynoldsburg, OH 43068 United States Hotline: (614) 861-5962

Welcome to Hickory House Restaurant

Nestled in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, Hickory House Restaurant stands out as a premier destination for steak and seafood lovers alike. This unforgettable eatery offers not just a meal, but a true dining experience, embodying warmth and comfort with its log cabin ambiance. Whether you're dining with family, friends, or even your four-legged companions on their outdoor patio, Hickory House embraces everyone with open arms.

A Culinary Journey

At Hickory House, the menu is a delightful blend of flavors that keeps patrons coming back for more. The star of the show is undoubtedly the Award Winning BarBQue Ribs, which are tender pork loin baby back ribs, generously basted in their signature homemade sauce. From the juicy Hickory House Wings served with a zesty barbecue or buffalo sauce to the light-and-crispy Onion Straws, each appetizer sets the stage for an indulgent meal.

  • Appetizers: Ribs, wings, onion straws, and sweet corn nuggets.
  • Main Dishes: Grilled shrimp, juicy filets, and an array of delicious seafood.
  • Sides: Hand-cut fries, macaroni and cheese, fresh seasonal vegetables, and more.
  • Desserts: Delightful cookie skillets and homemade cakes.

Recent diners, like Valerie S. and Steve T., have praised the grilled shrimp and steak, while Stephanie L. was blown away by the fall-off-the-bone ribs and overly friendly service, reminiscent of dining with family. This blend of attentive service and hearty portions makes every visit a memorable one.

Convenience and Comfort

Hickory House excels in offering convenience to its customers. The restaurant features:

  • Takeout and delivery options
  • Reservations and onsite parking
  • A full bar with happy hour specials
  • Outdoor seating, including heated and covered areas
  • A casual atmosphere perfect for families and groups

If you’re on the hunt for a restaurant that combines a casual atmosphere with mouth-watering dishes, Hickory House Restaurant is your ultimate destination. With a diverse menu that appeals to both meat lovers and vegetarians, there’s something for everyone at this beloved local establishment.

A Community Staple

With its warm reception, cozy décor, and consistent quality, Hickory House Restaurant is truly a stalwart of the Reynoldsburg community. As Mark B. emphasizes, it’s the perfect spot to gather with friends and family without breaking the bank. Each visit guarantees not only a delicious meal but also an experience enhanced by the friendly staff, making you feel right at home.

So, whether you're craving a steak dinner or some comforting BBQ, make your way to Hickory House Restaurant. Indulge in a meal that will satisfy your palate and warm your soul!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards